Welsh Open 2014 - Discussion

[DeanH]

Currently banned i think for being an Elite idiot

a month to consider his words/actions or a long term ban?
fingers-crossed

[scottley]

This site needs a like/favourite button

[jrc750]

The uploader of that vid, therocketexpress, is a member here I believe (arbitrage).

Currently banned i think for being an Elite idiot

[Holden Chinaski]

The uploader of that vid, therocketexpress, is a member here I believe (arbitrage).

[gavinpoo]

I guess they dubbed the BBC commentary onto the Eurosport feed because the BBC didn't broadcast in HD for this tournament.

[Billy]

Black to red on 56 is the definition of sublime and the reason he is so good.

Red to black on 104 (5:35) isn't bad either

[Tiger800]

Black to red on 56 is the definition of sublime and the reason he is so good.

[Billy]

He would have stripped out the audio of the Eurosport footage and then replaced the whole lot with the BBC audio. Relatively easy with free windows editing tools.

Why he did it I've no idea.

Out of curiosity I'd quite like to have heard the Eurosport commentary on this.

And as if my magic:

Mmm, rather uninspiring commentary in comparison. This is why, despite their faults, the BBC will never be bettered for snooker coverage. Yes, they've scrapped table choice on red button, they leave matches to show repeats of I've Made a Cake on Ice, Get Me Out of Here, but BBC is still the home of snooker in my opinion *


* I reserve the right to change my mind when they next **** me off.

[cyberheater]

I did consider that until I asked myself why he would go to such trouble. It would mean synching the BBC audio track with the footage exactly. I don't see how he could lift only the Eurosport commentary track and leave the other audio in place without some very specialised equipment.

He would have stripped out the audio of the Eurosport footage and then replaced the whole lot with the BBC audio. Relatively easy with free windows editing tools.

Why he did it I've no idea.

[Billy]

Mystery?
Eurosport purchase the BBC feed, then record their own commentary over that feed and broadcast that combination, I assume that this broadcast someone at Eurosport forgot to add the Eurosport commentary recording

I understand Eurosport feed off BBC's coverage, but that won't include the commentary, will it? And remember, Eurosport sometimes show live snooker at the same time as the BBC, so they must have the facility for feeding from picture only.

I think the guy who uploaded the youtube vid remixed the bbd audio commentary into it.

I did consider that until I asked myself why he would go to such trouble. It would mean synching the BBC audio track with the footage exactly. I don't see how he could lift only the Eurosport commentary track and leave the other audio in place without some very specialised equipment.

[cyberheater]

Mystery?
Eurosport purchase the BBC feed, then record their own commentary over that feed and broadcast that combination, I assume that this broadcast someone at Eurosport forgot to add the Eurosport commentary recording

I think the guy who uploaded the youtube vid remixed the bbd audio commentary into it.

[DeanH]

Can anyone explain the mystery behind this clip? It's the Eurosport broadcast but with the BBC Wales commentary?

Mystery?
Eurosport purchase the BBC feed, then record their own commentary over that feed and broadcast that combination, I assume that this broadcast someone at Eurosport forgot to add the Eurosport commentary recording

[robertmac]

His game is totally awesome and hopefully he will learn
some humility along the way.

[Billy]

Can anyone explain the mystery behind this clip? It's the Eurosport broadcast but with the BBC Wales commentary?

[Tiger800]

The last frame reminds me of a classic rock song, it's one of the only frames I have ever watched over and over and over lol